正规的快三平台

您当前的位置: 正规的快三平台 >> 示范文书 >> 辩护词 >> 内容

陈某三被控污染环境罪一案辩护词

办案律师/作者: 林航 来源:正规的快三平台 日期 : 2019-06-04

林航: 毒品、经济犯罪辩护律师、广东广强正规的快三平台毒品犯罪辩护与研究中心核心律师

 

SSHICQURENMINFAYUAN、ZUNJINGDESHENPANZHANG:

正规的快三平台FANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUSANBEIKONGWURANHUANJINGZUIYIAN,GUIYUANZHENGZAISHENLIZHONG。

正规的快三平台GUANGDONGGUANGQIANGZHENGGUIDEKUAISANPINGTAIJIESHOUCHENMOUSANJIQIJIASHUDEWEITUO,ZHIPAILINHANGLVSHIZAICHENMOUSANBEIKONGWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANZHONGDANRENCHENMOUSANDEBIANHUREN,YIFAWEIQITIGONGBIANHU。

正规的快三平台BIANHURENLIJIE、ZHICHIGUIYUANYIFADAJIWURANHUANJINGDEFANZUIXINGWEI,WEIHURENMINQUNZHONGDESHENGMINGJIANKANG、CAICHANANQUAN。TONGSHI,BIANHURENMINGBAIYINGDANGZAIFALVGUIDINGDEFANWEINEIWEIDANGSHIRENTIGONGBIANHU,JUEBUSHIWANGGUSHISHIYUFALV,WUZHONGSHENGYOU,WEISIFAJIGUANYIFABANANTIANJIAZHANGAI。RANER,BIANHURENTONGGUOYUEDUQUANBUANJUAN、HUIJIANCHENMOUSAN,RENWEIBENANYUQITADEWURANHUANJINGFANZUIANJIANYOUZHEZHONGDAQUBIE。WEILEXIEZHUGUIYUANZHENGQUEDAJIFANZUIHUODONG,TEXIANGGUIYUANCHUJUBIANHUCI,GONGGUIYUANZAIBANLICIANSHICANKAO。

正规的快三平台XINGFAYIYISHANGDEWURANHUANJINGSHIZHIXINGWEIRENJIANGYAOSHISHIHUOZHENGZAISHISHIDEXINGWEIWEIFANFANGZHIHUANJINGWURANDEXIANGGUANFALVGUIDING,BINGMINGZHIHUIDUIHUANJINGZAOCHENGYANZHONGWURANERRENGRANSHISHIZHEIYIXINGWEI,ZAOCHENGHUOFANGRENHUANJINGBEIYANZHONGWURANZHEIYISUNHAIJIEGUODEFASHENG。DUIWURANHUANJINGWUZHI、FEIWU、YOUDUWUZHIHUOZHEQITAYOUHAIWUZHIDERENDING,YIJIDUI“YANZHONGWURANHUANJING”BIAOZHUNDERENDING,YINGDANGFUHE《ZHONGHUARENMINGONGHEGUOXINGFA》、《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN、ZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANGUANYUBANLIHUANJINGWURANXINGSHIANJIANSHIYONGFALVRUOGANWENTIDEJIESHI》、《GUOJIAWEIXIANFEIWUMINGLU》(2016BAN)、GUANGDONGSHENGDIFANGBIAOZHUN《SHUIWURANWUPAIFANGXIANZHI》(DB44/26-2001)DENGXIANGGUANFALVGUIDING。

《QISUSHU》(CJIANYIBUXINGSU[2020]XXHAO)XIANSHI,GONGSUJIGUANRENWEI: “2013NIANKAISHIFANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUYIDEFUQINCHENMOUSIYINIANZUJIN80000YUANXIANGFANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUSANZUYONGQIWEIYUCQUGZHENHUAMEICUNHUAHUISILUDECHANGDIKAISHEFEIJIUSULIAOFENSUIGONGCHANG。”

“2019NIAN5YUEFENKAISHI,CHENMOUYIGUYONGFANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUERZAIGAIGONGCHANGNEICONGSHIFENSUI、QINGXISULIAOGONGZUO,SHENGCHANGUOCHENGZHONGCHANSHENGDEFEISHUITONGGUOANGUANPAIXIANGWAIBUHUANJING。”

“2019NIAN10YUE31RISHANGWUGAIGONGCHANGBEICHAHUOSHI,SSHISHENGTAIHUANJINGJUCQUFENJUDUIGONGCHANGWAIPAIFEISHUIJINXINGCHOUYANGJIANCE,JIELUNWEICODcr965(HUAXUEXUYANGLIANG)CHAOBIAO9.7BEI。JINGSSHIHUANJINGBAOHUJIANCEZHAN(XIAWENJIANCHENG“SSHIJIANCEZHAN”)JIANCE,WAIPAIFEISHUIZHONGZONGTONGHANLIANGCHAOBIAO4.0BEI,ZONGXINCHAOBIAO6.5BEI。”

“2017NIAN5YUE,BEIGAORENCHENMOUSANYINIANZUJIN60000YUANBAQIWEIYUCQUGZHENHUAMEICUNHUAXIANGPIANQUYITIEPENGZUJITONGANRENHUANGMOU(LINGANCHULI)。”

正规的快三平台“BEIGAORENCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERWEIFANGUOJIAGUIDINGTONGGUOANGUANTAOBIJIANGUANDEFANGSHIPAIFANGYOUDUWUZHI,YANZHONGWURANHUANJING,BEIGAORENCHENMOUSANTIGONGCHANGSUOGONGTARENPAIFANG、CHUZHIWURANWU,YANZHONGWURANHUANJING,QISANRENXINGWEIYICHUFAN《ZHONGHUARENMINGONGHEGUOXINGFA》DISANBAISANSHIBATIAO、DIERSHIWUTIAODEGUIDING,FANZUISHISHIQINGCHU,ZHENGJUQUESHICHONGFEN,YINGDANGYIWURANHUANJINGZUIZHUIJIUQIXINGSHIZEREN。”

QIZHONG,GONGSUJIGUANDERUZUISILUSHI,JIANGCHENMOUYIDENG“QINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUI”,RENDINGWEICHENMOUYIDENGSHISHILEWURANHUANJINGFANZUIXINGWEI、YANZHONGWURANHUANJINGDEYIJU;JIANGCHENMOUSAN“CHUZUTIEPENG”,RENDINGWEICHENMOUSANYUCHENMOUYI、HUANGMOUDENGGOUCHENGGONGTONGFANZUIDEYIJU。

ZHEIZHONGRUZUISILU,MINGXIANBUFUHEFALVDEGUIDINGJISIFACAIPANGUANDIAN,GENGBUFUHEZHENGGUIDEKUAISANPINGTAIDUIFALVCHANGSHIDERENZHI。BENANZHONG,CHENMOUSANWUFAYUCHENMOUYI、HUANGMOUDENGGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUIDEGONGTONGFANZUI,ERCHENMOUYIDENGSHISHIDEXINGWEIYUANWEIDADAOWURANHUANJINGZUIDEXINGSHIZHUISUBIAOZHUN,BUGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUI。

正规的快三平台BIANHURENJINGYIFACHAYUEANJUANCAILIAO,LEJIEANJIANSHISHI,ZONGHEQUANANZHENGJU,RENWEIBENANZHONGCHENMOUSANBUGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUI,JIANYIGUIYUANGENJU《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DIERBAITIAODEGUIDINGBOHUIGONGSURENDUICHENMOUSANDEZHIKONG,YIFAZUOCHUWUZUIPANJUE,JUTILIYOURUXIA:

正规的快三平台DIYI,DUICHENMOUSANCANYUCHENMOUYIDENGWURANHUANJINGZUIDEZHIKONG

BENANYOUZHENGJUZHENGMINGCHENMOUSANBUGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUI,YINGYIFARENDINGCHENMOUSANWUZUI。

DIER,DUICHENMOUSANCANYUHUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGZUIDEZHIKONG

BENANCHENMOUSANCANYUHUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGZUISHISHIBUQING、ZHENGJUBUZU,YIFAYINGYI“ZHENGJUBUZU、ZHIKONGDEFANZUIBUNENGCHENGLI”DUICHENMOUSANXUANGAOWUZUI。

 

第一部分

DUICHENMOUSANCANYUCHENMOUYIDENGWURANHUANJINGZUIDEZHIKONG,BENANYOUZHENGJUZHENGMINGCHENMOUSANWUZU,YINGYIFARENDINGCHENMOUSANWUZUI。

 

首先,本案无客观物证,在案证据无法证实陈某一通过暗管非法排放废水。

SSHICQUJIANCHAYUAN[SGONGCXINGSUZI(2020)XXXHAO]《QISUYIJIANSHU》(XIAWENJIANCHENG“QISUYIJIANSHU”)ZHIKONG: “2019NIAN5YUEFENKAISHI,CHENMOUYIGUYONGFANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUERZAIGAIGONGCHANGNEICONGSHIFENSUI、QINGXISULIAOGONGZUO,SHENGCHANGUOCHENGZHONGCHANSHENGDEFEISHUITONGGUOANGUANPAIXIANGWAIBUHUANJING。”

正规的快三平台YIJUANJIANSHISHIHEZAIANZHENGJU,BIANHURENRENWEI,《QISUSHU》DUICHENMOUYIDENGFEIFAQINGXISULIAO、WEIJINGFADINGPAIWUKOUERSHITONGGUOANGUANXIANGWAIBUHUANJINGPAIFANGFEISHUIDEZHIKONGSHISHIBUQING、ZHENGJUBUZU。ZHICHENGGAIKONGSUDEZHENGJUJINYOU《SSHISHENGTAIHUANJINGBAOHUZONGHEZHIFAJUCQUFENJUXIANCHANGJIANCHA(KANCHA)BILU》(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDIERJUANDI9YE,XIAWENJIANCHENGKANCHABILU)HECHENMOUYI、CHENXIANGDEZAIXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUZHONGDEGONGSHU,WURENHEWUZHENG、SHUZHENG、SHITINGZILIAOHUOQITAZHENGJUXIANGHUYINZHENG。

根据勘查笔录,“该店主要生产设备有粉粹机2台,洗料机1台、洗料桶1个……经现场勘查,该店车间清洗费塑料产生的废水未经法定排污口排放,而是通过车间地面排入店外西南侧的废水收集池。现场区生态环境检测站技术人员对该店外西南侧废水收集池(NXX°19′7″,EXXX正规的快三平台°21′18″)进行取样送检。”

正规的快三平台RUOKANCHABILUSUOSHUSHUSHI,ZE“FENCUIJI2TAI、XILIAOJI1TAI、XILIAOTONG1GEYIJIGAIGONGCHANGXINANCEDEFEISHUISHOUJICHIZHONGDEFEISHUI”DENGYINGDANGXIBENANZHENCHAHUODONGZHONGFAXIANDEKEYONGYUZHENGMINGFANZUIXIANYIRENYOUZUIHUOZHEWUZUIDEWUZHENG,GENJU《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DIYIBAISISHIYITIAO、DIYIBAISISHIERTIAO、《RENMINJIANCHAYUANXINGSHISUSONGGUIZE》DIERBAIYISHITIAO,BANANJIGUANYINGDANGDUISHANGSHUWUZHENGYIFACHAFENG、KOUYA。ERBANANJIGUANCHAFENG、KOUYASHANGSHUWUZHENGSHI,YINGDANGHUITONGZAICHANGJIANZHENGREN、WUZHENGCHIYOURENCHADIANQINGCHU,BINGDANGCHANGKAILIEQINGDANYISHIERFEN,YOUZHENCHARENYUAN、JIANZHENGRENHEWUZHENGCHIYOURENQIANMINGHUOZHEGAIZHANG,RANHOUBAYIFENQINGDANJIAOJIWUZHENGCHIYOUREN,LINGYIFENFUJUANBEICHA。

正规的快三平台DANSHI,BIANHURENZAIQUANMIANSHENYUEBENANZHENGJU、JUANZONGHOU,FAXIANBANANJIGUANMEIYOUANXIANGGUANFALVGUIDINGCHAFENG、KOUYASHANGSHUWUZHENG,GENGMEIYOUZHIZUOWUZHENGDECHAFENG、KOUYAQINGDAN、BILU。SUIRANKANCHABILUHOUFUSHANGLEXIANCHANGKANCHASHISUOPAISHEDEBUFENZHAOPIAN,DANZHEIXIEZHAOPIANBIAODANEIRONGHUNLUAN,WEINENGXIANSHIXIANCHANGCUNZAISHANGSHUWUZHENG,TEBIESHIFEISHUIQUYANGDEZHAOPIAN,ZHAOPIANZHONGZHINENGKANDAOBANANRENYUANNAZHEPINGZIZHUSHUIDEYANGZI,ERQUYANGHOUDEPINGZHUANGFEISHUIYANGPINJIMEIYOUZHANGZHAOPIAN,YEMEIYOUGUANYUSUOTIQUDEFEISHUIYANGBENDETIJI、ZHILIANG、WAIGUANTEZHENGDENGXIANGGUANMIAOSHU。

正规的快三平台LINGWAI,ANFAHOU,BANANJIGUANMEIYOUDUIWEIYUSSHICQUGZHENHUAMEICUNHUAHUISILUDESHEANCHANGDIJINXINGCHAFENG,BIANHURENZAIDUIANFAXIANCHANGJINGGUOSHIDIKAOCHASHI,FAXIANGAICHANGDINEIKONGDANGWUWU,MEIYOUFAXIANBANANJIGUANZAI《KANCHABILU》ZHONGSUOTIDE“FENCUIJI2TAI、XILIAOJI1TAI、XILIAOTONG1GE”。

 

 

(SHANGMIANLIANGTUWEIANFAHOUCQUGZHENHUAMEICUNHUAHUISILUDETIEPENGDENEIBUZHAOPIAN)

GENJUZAIANZHENGJU,YIJIBIANHURENSHIDILEJIEDAODEQINGKUANG,RANGRENBUDEBUCHANSHENGYIXIADEHELIHUAIYI: BENANDAODIYOUMEIYOUCHAFENG、KOUYADAOXIANGGUANWUZHENG?SHIFOUGENBENJIUBUCUNZAI《KANCHABILU》SUOSHUDEXIANGGUANWUZHENG?RUGUOZHENDEYOUWUZHENG,WEIHEQUANANJUANZONGJUNWUCHAFENG、KOUYAXIANGGUANWUZHENGDEJILU?BENANDAODIYOUMEIYOUTIQUDAOFEISHUIYANGBEN?RUGUOTIQUDAOLEFEISHUIYANGBEN,WEINENGZAIJUANZONGLIKANDAO “FEISHUIYANGBEN”DEKOUYAQINGDAN、YIJIAOQINGDANYEJIUSUANLE,WEIHELIANYIZHANG“FEISHUIYANGBEN”DEZHAOPIANDOUMEIYOU?BANANRENYUANSHIFOUGENBENMEIYOUWANCHENGFEISHUIQUYANGGONGZUO?RUGUOQUESHICHAFENG、KOUYADAOLEXIANGGUANWUZHENG,YETIQUDAOLE“FEISHUIYANGBEN”,NEIMEZHEIXIEWUZHENGXIANZAIBEIBAOGUANYUHECHU?XIANGGUANWUZHENGYIJITIQUDE“FEISHUIYANGBEN”SHIFOUZAICHAFENG、KOUYAHOUZAODAOSUNHAI、HUIMIEHUOWURAN,SANGSHILEZHENGMINGLI?

BIANHURENRENWEI,GENJUZAIANZHENGJU,GENBENWUFAPAICHUSHANGSHUHELIHUAIYI,YINWEIBENANGENBENMEIYOU《KANCHABILU》SUOTIDAODE“FENCUIJI2TAI、XILIAOJI1TAI、XILIAOTONG1GEYIJIGAIGONGCHANGXINANCEDEFEISHUISHOUJICHIZHONGDEFEISHUI”DENGXIANGGUANWUZHENG,BENANXIANYOUDEZHENGJUWUFAZHENGSHICHENMOUYIDENGTONGGUOANGUANFEIFAPAIFANGFEISHUI。

 

(SHANGTUWEISSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDIERJUANDI11YE)

 

其次,本案两份检测报告(S市公安局C区分局刑事侦查卷宗第二卷第40-45页)的真实性与关联性存疑。

正规的快三平台《QISUSHU》ZHIKONG: “2019NIAN10YUE31RISHANGWUGAIGONGCHANGBEICHAHUOSHI,SSHISHENGTAIHUANJINGJUCQUFENJUDUIGONGCHANGWAIPAIFEISHUIJINXINGCHOUYANGJIANCE,JIELUNWEICODcr965(HUAXUEXUYANGLIANG)CHAOBIAO9.7BEI。JINGSSHIHUANJINGBAOHUJIANCEZHAN(XIAWENJIANCHENG“SSHIJIANCEZHAN”)JIANCE,WAIPAIFEISHUIZHONGZONGTONGHANLIANGCHAOBIAO4.0BEI,ZONGXINCHAOBIAO6.5BEI。”

正规的快三平台GENJUZAIANZHENGJU,BIANHURENRENWEI,SUIRAN,KANCHABILUXIANSHI: “XIANCHANGQUSHENGTAIHUANJINGJIANCEZHANJISHURENYUANDUIGAIDIANWAIXINANCEFEISHUISHOUJICHI(NXX°19′7″,EXXX°21′18″)JINXINGQUYANGSONGJIAN。”DANSHI,ZONGHEQUANANZHENGJUCAILIAO,BENANJIMEIYOUDUI“FEISHUI”QUYANGGUOCHENGDESHIPINYINPINZILIAO,YEMEIYOU“FEISHUIYANGPIN”DESHIWU、ZHAOPIAN,JIULIAN“FEISHUIYANGPIN”DETIJI、ZHILIANGDENGXIANGGUANSHUJUDOUMEIYOU。YINCI,BENANMEIYOUZHENGJUNENGZHENGSHIBANANJIGUANHUOCQUJIANCEZHANQUDELECHENMOUYIDENGTONGGUOANGUANPAIFANGDEFEISHUIDESHUIYANG。

正规的快三平台LINGWAI,SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDIERJUANDI40-45YEXIEDAO,JIANCEBAOGAO[(CQU)HUANJINGJIANCESCZI(2019DI113HAO)]XIYOUSSHICQUHUANJINGBAOHUJIANCEZHANZUOCHU,ERJIANCEBAOGAO[(SSHI)HUANJINGJIANCEESZI(2019)DIXXXXXXXXXXXXXHAO]XIYOUSSHIHUANJINGBAOHUJIANCEZHANZUOCHU。DANSHI,ZONGHEQUANANZHENGJU,JIWUSSHICQUHUANJINGBAOHUJIANCEZHAN(XIAWENJIANCHENGCQUJIANCEZHAN)XIANGSSHIJIANCEZHANYIJIAOJIANYANCAILIAODEXIANGGUANSHOUXU,YEMEIYOUCQUJIANCEZHANDUISONGJIANYANGPINDEXIANGGUANSHUOMINGHUOZHENGMINGCAILIAO,GENGWUSSHIJIANCEZHANDUIJIESHOUDAODESONGJIANYANGPINDEQUEREN、SHUOMING。

正规的快三平台   

正规的快三平台(SHANGTUWEILIANGFENJIANCEBAOGAODEFENGMIAN)

正规的快三平台YINCI,GENJUZAIANZHENGJU,JIWUFARENDINGCQUJIANCEZHANSHIFOUQUDELECHENMOUYIFEIFAPAIFANGDE“FEISHUIYANGPIN”,YIWUZHENGJUZHENGSHICQUJIANCEZHANXIANGSSHIJIANCEZHANYIJIAOLEJIANYANCAILIAO(CHENMOUSANDENGFEIFAPAIFANGDE“FEISHUIYANGBEN”),GENGWUFAQUEDINGCQUJIANCEZHANSUOJIANCEDESHUIYANG(YANGPINBIANHAO: S191031XX)YUSSHIJIANCEZHANSUOJIANCEDESHUIYANG(YANGPINBIANHAO: SXXX)SHIBUSHICHENMOUYIDENGFEIFAPAIFANGDEFEISHUIDEYANGPIN。

 

再次,退一万步,即使办案机关搜集到了陈某一等非法排放的“废水样本”,本案的两份监测报告真实有效且与本案有关联性,但两份监测报告的检测结果均未达到污染环境罪的刑事追诉标准。

正规的快三平台JIANCEBAOGAO[(CQU)HUANJINGJIANCESCZI(2019DI113HAO)]DEJIANCEJIEGUOXIANSHI,SONGJIANDESHUIYANG(YANGPINBIANHAO: S191031XX)pHZHI(SUANJIANDU)WEI7.2,DADAOGUANGDONGSHENGDIFANGBIAOZHUN《SHUIWURANWUPAIFANGXIANZHI》(DB44/26-2001)DEPAIFANGBIAOZHUN;SONGJIANSHUIYANG(YANGPINBIANHAO: S191031XX)CODcrZHI(YIZHONGGESUANYANFACEDINGDEHUAXUEXUYANGLIANG)WEI965mg/L,CHAOGUOGUANGDONGSHENGDIFANGBIAOZHUN《SHUIWURANWUPAIFANGXIANZHI》(DB44/26-2001)9.7BEI,BAOGAOTONGSHIXIANSHI: “‘ZUOFANGWAIXINANCEFEISHUISHOUJICHI’(YANGPINBIANHAO: S191031XX)DESHUIYANGCAIYANGXIANCHANGWUWAIPAI”,ZHEISHUOMINGLE,SUIRANSHUIYANG(YANGPINBIANHAO: S191031XX)DEJIANCEJIEGUOXIANSHIQIHUAXUEXUYANGLIANGCHAOBIAO9.7BEI,DANFEISHUIWEIBEIPAIWANGWAIHUANJING,YINCIWUFADUIWAIHUANJINGZAOCHENGSHIZHIYINGXIANG。

正规的快三平台JIANCEBAOGAO[(SHANSHI)HUANJINGJIANCEESZI(2019)DI2010XXXHAO]DEJIANCEJIEGUOXIANSHI,SHUIYANGYANGPINBIANHAO: SXXX(DUIYINGCQUJIANCEZHANSHUIYANGYANGPINBIANHAO: S191031XX)DEJIANCEJIEGUOWEI“ZONGGEHANLIANG0054mg/L,ZONGTONGHANLIANG2.48mg/L,ZONGXINHANLIANG15.0mg/L”。

GENJU《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN、ZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUANGUANYUBANLIHUANJINGWURANXINGSHIANJIANSHIYONGFALVRUOGANWENTIDEJIESHI》(XIAWENZHONGJIANCHENG“HUANJINGJIESHI”)DIYITIAODI(SAN)XIANG、DI(SI)XIANG,MANZUXINGFADISANBAISANSHIBATIAO“YANZHONGWURANHUANJING”DEXINGSHIZHUISUBIAOZHUN,YAOQIUXINGWEIRENPAIFANG、QINGDAO、CHUZHIDEHANGEWURANWUCHAOGUOGUOJIAHUOZHEDIFANGWURANWUPAIFANGBIAOZHUNSANBEIYISHANG,HUOXINGWEIRENPAIFANG、QINGDAO、CHUZHIDEHANTONG、XINWURANWUCHAOGUOGUOJIAHUOZHEDIFANGWURANWUPAIFANGBIAOZHUNSHIBEIYISHANG。YOUGENJU《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN、ZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUAN、GONGANBU、SIFABU、SHENGTAIHUANJINGBUGUANYUBANLIHUANJINGWURANXINGSHIANJIANYOUGUANWENTIZUOTANHUIJIYAO》DI4TIAO,“HUIYIZHICHU,《HUANJINGJIESHI》JIANGZAOCHENGSHENGTAIHUANJINGSUNHAIGUIDINGWEIWURANHUANJINGZUIDEDINGZUILIANGXINGBIAOZHUNZHIYI,SHIWEILEYUSHENGTAIHUANJINGSUNHAIPEICHANGZHIDUSHIXIANXIANJIEPEITAO,KAOLVDAOGAIZHIDUSHANGZAISHIXINGGUOCHENGZHONG,《HUANJINGJIESHI》ZUOLEJIAOYUANZEDEGUIDING。SIFASHIJIANZHONG,YIXIESHENGSHIJIEHEBENDIQUGONGZUOSHIJIZHIDINGLEJUTIBIAOZHUN。HUIYIRENWEI,ZAISHENGTAIHUANJINGSUNHAIPEICHANGZHIDUSHIXINGJIEDUAN,QUANGUOGESHENG(ZIZHIQU、ZHIXIASHI)KEYIJIEHEBENDISHIJIQINGKUANG,YINDIZHIYI,YINSHIZHIYI,GENJUANJIANJUTIQINGKUANGZHUNQUERENDING‘ZAOCHENGSHENGTAIHUANJINGYANZHONGSUNHAI’HE‘ZAOCHENGSHENGTAIHUANJINGTEBIEYANZHONGSUNHAI’。”

正规的快三平台BENANSUOYIJUDEBIAOZHUNWEI“GUANGDONGSHENGDIFANGBIAOZHUN《SHUIWURANWUPAIFANGXIANZHI》(DB44/26-2001)”。ERBENANDELIANGFENJIANCEBAOGAOXIANSHI,SHUIYANGYANGPINBIANHAO: SXXXDEZONGGEPAIFANGFUHEBIAOZHUNFUHE“GUANGDONGSHENGDIFANGBIAOZHUN《SHUIWURANWUPAIFANGXIANZHI》(DB44/26-2001)”DIYILEIWURANWUZUIGAOYUNXUPAIFANGNONGDUBIAOZHUN。YOUGENJUGAIBIAOZHUNDIERLEIWURANWUZUIGAOYUNXUPAIFANGNONGDUDI18XIANGZONGTONGPAIFANGYIJIBIAOZHUN(0.5mg/L)、DI19XIANGZONGXINPAIFANGYIJIBIAOZHUN(2.0mg/L),SUIRANSHUIYANGYANGPINBIANHAO: SXXXDEZONGTONGPAIFANGCHAOBIAO4.0BEI、ZONGXINPAIFANGCHAOBIAO6.5BEI。

YINCI,BENANSHUIYANGDETONG、XINWURANWUCHAOBIAOCHENGDUJUNYUANWEIDADAOHUANJINGJIESHIDIYITIAODI(SAN)XIANG、DI(SI)XIANGSUOYAOQIUDE“XINGWEIRENPAIFANG、QINGDAO、CHUZHIDEHANTONG、XINWURANWUCHAOGUOGUOJIAHUOZHEDIFANGWURANWUPAIFANGBIAOZHUNSHIBEIYISHANG”DEWURANHUANJINGZUIXINGSHIZHUISUBIAOZHUN。

 

正规的快三平台(JIANCEBAOGAO[(SHANSHI)HUANJINGJIANCEESZI(2019)DI2010XXXHAO]DESHUOMINGDEJIETU)

综上,化学需氧量现在仍不能作为污染环境罪定罪量刑的依据,更何况废水未被排往外环境,未对外环境造成影响。而水样样品编号: SXXX的总铜排放超标4.0倍、总锌排放超标6.5倍,虽然已经超过了广东省地方标准《水污染物排放限值》(DB44/26-2001)的污染物排放标准,但仍远未能满足环境解释“排放、倾倒、处置含…铜、锌…的污染物,超过国家或者地方污染物排放标准十倍以上。”的刑事追诉要求。而本案更未查到陈某一等有排放、倾倒、处置有放射性的废物、含传染病病原体的废物、有毒物质的行为。因此,本案目前的在案证据根本没有可证实陈某三以及陈某一等应当承担刑事责任的事实与证据。

 

最后,在案证据不能证实陈某三与陈某一等构成污染环境罪的共同犯罪。

《QISUSHU》ZHIKONG: “2013NIANKAISHIFANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUYIDEFUQINCHENMOUSIYINIANZUJIN80000YUANXIANGFANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUSANZUYONGQIWEIYUCQUGZHENHUAMEICUNHUAHUISILUDECHANGDIKAISHEFEIJIUSULIAOFENSUIGONGCHANG……2019NIAN5YUEFENKAISHI,CHENMOUYIGUYONGFANZUIXIANYIRENCHENMOUERZAIGAIGONGCHANGNEICONGSHIFENSUI、QINGXISULIAOGONGZUO,SHENGCHANGUOCHENGZHONGCHANSHENGDEFEISHUITONGGUOANGUANPAIXIANGWAIBUHUANJING。”

GENJUZAIANZHENGJUJIANJIANSHISHI,BIANHURENRENWEI,《QISUSHU》ZHIKONG“CHENMOUSANMINGZHICHENMOUYISHISHIWURANHUANJINGDEFANZUIXINGWEIRENGWEIQITIGONGCHANGSUO”SHISHIBUQING、ZHENGJUBUZU,BENANWUZHENGJUZHICHENGCIKONGSU,JUTIDESHISHIYULIYOURUXIA。

正规的快三平台GENJUCHENMOUSIZAIQIXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUZHONGDEGONGSHU: “WEN: NIXIANGCHENMOUSANZUYONGTIEPIWUZUOHESHENGYI?DA: WOZULAIKAISHEFEIJIUSULIAOFENJIANGONGCHANG。……WEN: NIJINGYINGGONGCHANGQIJIANDESHENGCHANLIUCHENGSHIZENYANGDE?DA: GONGRENDUIFEIJIUSULIAOJINXINGFENJIANFENLEI,RANHOUDABAOCHUSHOU。WEN: GONGCHANGZAIZUOYEGONGCHENGZHONGSHIFOUHUICHANSHENGFEISHUI?DA: BUHUICHANSHENGFEISHUI。……WEN: CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUSHIFOUYOUDUIFEIJIUSULIAOJINXINGQINGXI?DA: WOBUQINGCHU。WEN: CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANG?DA: ZAIWOJINGYINGQIJIAN,CHENMOUSANOUERYOUDAOGONGCHANGZHAOWOXIANLIAOHECHA,CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANGLAIWOJIUBUQINGCHULE。WEN: NIJINGYINGQIJIANSHIFOUYOUDUISULIAOJINXINGQINGXI?DA: MEIYOU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI124、 125YE),“……WEN: CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANG?DA: ZAIWOJINGYINGQIJIANCHENMOUSANOUERYOUDAOGONGCHANGLAIXIANLIAOHECHA,2018NIAN11YUECHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANGLAIWOJIUBUQINGCHULE。……WEN: NIBENRENKAIBANHEJINGYINGFEIJIUSULIAOGONGCHANGQIJIANSHIFOUHUIDUIHUANJINGHUIZAOCHENGWURAN?DA: WOZHISHIDUIFEIJIUSULIAOJINXINGFENJIAN,BUHUIDUIHUANJINGHUIZAOCHENGWURAN。”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI129、130YE)

正规的快三平台GENJUCHENMOUYIZAIQIXUNWENBILUZHONGGONGSHU: “……WEN: CUOZHUCHENMOUSANZAINIJIESHOUZUOFANGQIJIANSHIFOUYOUQUGUOGAIZUOFANG?DA: YOUQUGUOJICI,JUTIDUOSHAOCIWOJIBUQINGCHU。WEN: CHENMOUSANMEICIDAONIZUOFANGSHI,ZUOFANGSHIFOUYOUZAIZUOYE?DA: YOUSHIHOUYOU,YOUSHIHOUMEIYOU。WEN: CHENMOUSANDAONIZUOFANGSHI,NIZUOFANGDEZUOYEZHUANGKUANG?DA: TADAOHOU,GONGRENZHISHIZAIWOZUOFANGFENJIANSULIAO。WEN: CHENMOUSANDAONIZUOFANGSHI,SHIFOUYOUKANJIANNIMENZAIQINGXISULIAO?DA: MEIYOU。WEN: TASHIFOUZHIDAONIZUOFANGZAICONGSHIQINGXISULIAOZUOYE?DA: TABUQINGCHU,WOMEIYOUHETASHUOGUO。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI133、134YE),“……WEN: NIJIESHOUQIAN,NIFUQINKAISHEDEZUOFANGSHIZAICONGSHIHESHENGCHAN?DA: CONGSHIFENJIANSULIAOZUOYE。…….WEN: NIFUQINCHENMOUSISHIFOUQINGCHUNIZAIGAIZUOFANGCONGSHIFENSUI、QINGXIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOYE?DA: TABUQINGCHU。……WEN: CHENMOUSANSHIFOUQINGCHUNIZAIGAICHANGDIGANSHENME?DA: DANGSHISHIWOFUQINHETAZUDE,TASHIFOUQINGCHUZULAIGANSHENMEDEWOYEBUZHIDAO。(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI151、155YE)”

正规的快三平台GENJUCHENMOUERZAIQIXUNWEN、XUNWEN、BIANRENBILUZHONGGONGSHU: “……WEN: NISHIFOURENSHINIDAGONGDEZUOFANGCUOZHU?DA: WOBURENSHI。WEN: CUOZHUSHIFOUYOUDAOGUOGAIZUOFANG?DA: WOBURENSHITA,WOBUQINGCHUGAIZUOFANGCUOZHUSHIFOUYOULAIGUOGAIZUOFANG。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI166YE),“……WEN: GAIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOFANGDECHANGDISHISHEIDE?DA: WOTINGLAOBANSHUOCHANGDISHIXIANGBIERENZUDE,JUTIXIANGSHEIZUDEWOBUQINGCHU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI170YE),“……WEN: GAIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOFANGDECUOZHUSHISHEI?DA: WOTINGLAOBANSHUOCHANGDISHIXIANGBIERENZUDE,JUTIXIANGSHEIZUDEWOBUQINGCHU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI175YE),“……WEN: GAIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOFANGDECUOZHUSHISHEI?DA: WOTINGLAOBANSHUOCHANGDISHIXIANGBIERENZUDE,JUTIXIANGSHEIZUDEWOBUQINGCHU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI180YE),“JINGWOBIANRENZHAOPIANZHONGDERENWODOUBURENSHI。”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI188YE)

ERDUIYUCHENMOUSANDEXIANGGUANXUNWEN、XUNWENBILU,BIANHURENZIXISHENYUEANJUANHOU,HUIJIANCHENMOUSANSHI,BEICHENMOUSANGAOZHI:

正规的快三平台2018NIAN11YUE7RI,CHENMOUSANYUCHENMOUSIQIANDING《CANGKUZULINHETONG》(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDIERJUANDI44YE),SHUANGFANGYUEDING: CHENMOUSANJIANGWEIYUGZHENHUAMEIHUAHUISILUTIEPICHANGFANGCHENGZUJICHENMOUSISHIYONG,ZUQIYINIAN,NIANZUJINRENMINBIBAWANYUAN。HETONGQIANDINGHOU,CHENMOUSANBACHANGFANGDESUOYOUYAOCHIDOUJIAOJILECHENMOUSI,QIWUFAZIZHUCHURUGAICHANGFANG。SUIRAN,CHENMOUSANZAIZULINQIJIANOUERDAOGUOCHANGFANGZOUDONG,DANQICONGBUFAXIANCHANGFANGNEISHEZHIYOU“FENSUIJI2TAIYIJIQITA1TAIBUZHIMINGJIXIE”,YICONGWEIFAXIANCHENMOUSIHUOCHENMOUYIDENGZAIGAICHANGFANGNEIFEIFAQINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUIHUOCONGSHIQITADEWURANHUANJINGDEFEIFAJINGYING、SHENGCHANHUODONG。BENANANFAHOU,CHENMOUSANCAICHUBULEJIEDAOCHENMOUYIDENGZAIQICHUZUDECHANGFANGNEICONGSHIWURANHUANJINGDEFEIFASHENGCHANJINGYINGXINGWEI。

正规的快三平台XINGFADISANBAISANSHIBATIAOGUIDING,WEIFANGUOJIAGUIDING,PAIFANG、QINGDAOHUOZHECHUZHIYOUFANGSHEXINGDEFEIWU、HANCHUANRANBINGBINGYUANTIDEFEIWU、YOUDUWUZHIHUOZHEQITAYOUHAIWUZHI,YANZHONGWURANHUANJINGDE,CHUSANNIANYIXIAYOUQITUXINGHUOZHEJUYI,BINGCHUHUOZHEDANCHUFAJIN;HOUGUOTEBIEYANZHONGDE,CHUSANNIANYISHANGQINIANYIXIAYOUQITUXING,BINGCHUFAJIN。XINGFADIERSHIWUTIAO,GONGTONGFANZUISHIZHIERRENYISHANGGONGTONGGUYIFANZUI。ERRENYISHANGGONGTONGGUOSHIFANZUI,BUYIGONGTONGFANZUILUNCHU;YINGDANGFUXINGSHIZERENDE,ANZHAOTAMENSUOFANDEZUIFENBIECHUFA。HUANJINGJIESHIDIQITIAOGUIDING,MINGZHITARENWUWEIXIANFEIWUJINGYINGXUKEZHENG,XIANGQITIGONGHUOZHEWEITUOQISHOUJI、ZHUCUN、LIYONG、CHUZHIWEIXIANFEIWU,YANZHONGWURANHUANJINGDE,YIGONGTONGFANZUILUNCHU。

GENJUXIANGGUANFALVGUIDING,JIEHEZAIANZHENGJU,BIANHURENRENWEI: CHENMOUSI、CHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERDUOCIZAIXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUZHONGDEGONGSHUJUNNENGBAOCHIYIZHIXING,QIESANRENZHIJIANDEGONGSHUNENGGOUXINGCHENGXIANGHUYINZHENG,KEXINDUJIAOGAO。

正规的快三平台DANSHI,YOUYUCHENMOUSANTICHUBANANRENYUANCUNZAIYOUGONG、PIANGONGSHENZHIWEIZAOXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUDEXINGWEI,BIANHURENWUFADIAOQUDEDAODUICHENMOUSANDEXUNWEN、XUNWENLUYINLUXIANGZILIAO,YINCI,WUFAPAICHUCHENMOUSANDEXIANGGUANXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUCUNZAIPIANGONG、YOUGONGSHENZHIXIWEIZAOBILUDEHELIHUAIYI,BIANHURENJIANYIGUIYUANDUICHENMOUSANZAIQIXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUZHONGDEGONGSHUBUYUCAIXIN。

正规的快三平台LINGWAI,GENJUZAIANZHENGJU,JIEHECHENMOUSANDUIBIANHURENDECHENSHU,SHEANDEHUOWU、WURANWUJUNSHUTARENSUOYOU,BINGJUNYOUTARENSUOMAIMAI、PAIFANG、QINGDAOHUOCHUZHI,YUCHENMOUSANWUGUAN;BENANWURANHUANJINGDENGFEIFAJINGYING、SHENGCHANHUODONGJUNYOUTARENCEHUA、ZUZHIJISHISHI,YUCHENMOUSANWUGUAN;CHENMOUSANMEIYOUXIANGTARENTIGONGHUOZHEWEITUOTARENSHOUJI、ZHUCUN、LIYONG、CHUZHIWEIXIANWUZHI;CHENMOUSANDUICHENMOUYIDENGQINGXISULIAO、TONGGUOANGUANFEIFAPAIFANGFEISHUIDEBUFAXINGWEIBINGBUZHIQING,ZAIANZHENGJUWUFARENDINGCHENMOUSANGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUI。JUTIDESHISHIYULIYOUYOUYIXIASANDIAN:

一,涉案的货物、污染物与陈某三无关,陈某三未参与陈某一等实施的污染环境犯罪活动。

GENJUBENANZAIANZHENGJU,JIBIANHURENHUIJIANCHENMOUSANSHILEJIEDAODESHISHI,2018NIAN11YUE,CHENMOUSIYUCHENMOUSANQIANDING《CANGKUZULINHETONG》,CHENMOUSANBASHEANCHANGDIZUJILECHENMOUSI。CHENMOUSIZAI2018NIAN12YUEBASHEANGONGCHANGJIAOYUCHENMOUYIJINGYINGGUANLI,2019NIAN5YUEFENKAISHI,CHENMOUYIKAISHIZAIGAIGONGCHANGNEICONGSHIFENSUI、QINGXISULIAOGONGZUOBINGTONGGUOANGUANFEIFAPAIFANGFEISHUI。CHENMOUSANCHUXIANGCHENMOUSI、CHENMOUYIDENGSHOUQUSHUANGFANGYUEDINGDEZUJINWAI,QIYUCHENMOUSI、CHENMOUYIDENGBINGWUQITAJINGJIWANGLAI,BENANWULUNSHIANFAQIANHAISHIANFAHOU,CHENMOUSANMEIYOUZAICHENMOUSIHUOBENANQITAXIANYIRENCHUHUODERENHEKEYI、FEIFALIYI,YOUCIKEJIAN,CHENMOUSANBINGWEIDASUANTONGGUOCANYUSHEANWURANHUANJINGDEBUFAHUODONGLAIHUOLI。LINGWAI,CHENMOUSANYICONGWEIWEITUOHUOCANYUSHEANHUOWU、WURANWUDEMAIMAI、PAIFANG、QINGDAOHUOCHUZHIDENGBUFAHUODONG,GENJUCHENMOUYIYIJICHENMOUERDEGONGSHU,BENANWURANHUANJINGDENGFEIFAJINGYING、SHENGCHANHUODONGJUNYOUCHENMOUYIDENGCEHUA、ZUZHIJISHISHI,ERQINGXISULIAOJIPAIFANGFEISHUIDEGONGZUOBIANYOUCHENMOUERJUTISHISHI,YUCHENMOUSANWUGUAN。

正规的快三平台GENJU《CANGKUZULINHETONG》,SHEANCHANGDIZUQIWEIYINIAN,NIANZUJINWEIBAWAN,GAIZUJINJIAGEYUANFACHANGDIFUJINQITATONGLEIXINGCHANGFANGDEZUJINJIAGEBINGWUCHURU,YOUCIKEJIAN,CHENMOUSANBINGWEISHITUTONGGUOSHOUQUGAOEZUJINDEFANGSHICONGCHENMOUYIDENGDEFEIFASHENGCHANJINGYINGHUODONGZHONGHUOLI。ERQIE,CHENMOUSANTONGGUOJINGYINGQIMINGXIADESHANGPUZULINDENGDENGQITAHEFATUJINGBIANKEHUODEKEGUANDEHEFASHOURU,ZHEIXIEHEFASHOURUZUYISHICHENMOUSANJIQIJIARENGUOSHANGJIAOWEIFUZUDESHENGHUO,YINCI,CHENMOUSANWANQUANMEIYOUMAOZHECHENGDANXINGSHIZERENDEFENGXIANQUMOUQULIYIDEXUQIU,TAMEIYOUFANZUIDONGJIYUMUDE。

正规的快三平台BENANANFAHOU,ZAICHENMOUSANSHOUDAOCHUANHUANZHENGSHI,YISHIQIBENANTAXIANYIRENBEIZHUABUGUIANBANGEYUEZUOYOUDESHIHOULE,TAZISHIZHIZHONGMEIYOUQIANTAOHUOTAOBIZHENCHA,ERSHIZAISHOUDAOCHUANHUANZHENGHOU,ZHUDONGQIANWANGGONGANJIGUANPEIHEDIAOCHA,ZHEIYEZAIYIDINGCHENGDUSHANGZHENGMINGLECHENMOUSANBINGWEICANYUSHISHISHEANDEWURANHUANJINGDENGBUFAXINGWEI,QIEQIDUICHENMOUYIGONGCHANGDESHENGCHANJINGYINGZHUANGKUANGBUZHIQING,YEZHENGMINGLEBENANDEHUOWU、WURANWUYIJIXIANGGUANWURANHUANJINGDEBUFAXINGWEIJUNYUCHENMOUSANWUGUAN。

二,在案证据可以证实陈某三从未知道陈某一等实施“非法清洗塑料、排放废水”的污染环境犯罪行为。

GENJUCHENMOUSIDEGONGSHU,QIYU2013NIANKAISHIBIANXIANGCHENMOUSANZUYONGSHEANCHANGDI,BINGZAICHANGDINEIKAISHEFEIJIUSULIAOFENJIANGONGCHANG,DANQIGONGCHANGJINDUIFEIJIUSULIAOJINXINGFENJIANYIJIDABAOZUOYE,SHENGCHANJINGYINGGUOCHENGBUHUICHANSHENGFEISHUI,GENGBUHUIDUIWAIBUHUANJINGZAOCHENGWURAN。

GENJUCHENMOUYIDEGONGSHU,QIYU2018NIAN12YUEJIESHOUSHEANFEIJIUSULIAOFENJIANGONGCHANG,BINGYU2019NIAN5YUEKAISHIZAIGAIGONGCHANGNEIKAISHIFENSUI、QINGXISULIAOGONGZUO,SHENGCHANGUOCHENGZHONGCHANSHENGDEFEISHUIWEIJINGFADINGPAIWUKOUERSHITONGGUOANGUANPAIXIANGWAIBUHUANJING,CHENMOUSANZAICIQIJIANSUIRANYOUDAOGUOGONGCHANGXIANCHANG,DANCHENMOUSANDAOGONGCHANGSHI,CHANGNEIGONGRENZHISHIZAIFENJIANSULIAO,CHENMOUSANWEINENGFAXIANTAMENYOUQINGXISULIAOHUOQINGDAOFEISHUI。

GENJUCHENMOUERDEGONGSHUJIBIANRENBILU,QIBUZHIDAOSHEANGONGCHANGDEFANGDONGSHISHEI,GENGBURENSHICHENMOUSANSHIHEXURENYE,ZHEIYEZHENGKEYIYUCHENMOUYIDEGONGSHUXIANGHUYINZHENG,CONGCEMIANZHENGMINGCHENMOUSANDUIZEPENGDENGZAIGONGCHANGNEI“FEIFAQINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUI”XIANGGUANZHUANGKUANGBINGBUZHIQING。

CHENMOUSANYIDUIBIANHURENCHENSHU,BENANANFAQIAN,QIQUEYOUDAOGUOSHEANGONGCHANG,DANBINGWEIFAXIANXIANCHANGYOUSHENMEJIQI,GENGWEIFAXIANGONGCHANGNEIYOUGONGRENZAIQINGXISULIAOHUOPAIFANGFEISHUI。

正规的快三平台JIEHEQITAZAIANZHENGJUKEZHI,YU2018NIAN11YUEXIANGCHENMOUSANCHENGZUSHEANCHANGSUODERENSHICHENMOUSI,ERCHENMOUSIDESHENGCHANJINGYINGXINGWEIBINGBUHUIZAOCHENGHUANJINGWURAN,2018NIAN12YUE,CHENMOUSIBASHEANZUOFANGJIAOJICHENMOUYIFUZESHENGCHANJINGYING,CHENMOUYIJIESHOUSHEANZUOFANGZHICHU,YEBINGWEIZAOCHENGWURANHUANJING,ZHIDAO2019NIAN5YUE,CHENMOUYICAIKAISHIZAISHEANCHANGSUONEISHISHI“FEIFAQINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUI”DEWURANHUANJINGFANZUIHUODONG。CHENMOUYIKAISHI“FEIFAQINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUI”HOU,QICONGWEIBAZHEIYISHISHIGAOZHICHENMOUSIYUCHENMOUSAN,ERDANGCHENMOUSANDAOGONGCHANGXIANCHANG,GONGRENGENGSHIMEIYOUJINXING“QINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUI”DEZUOYE。

LINGWAI,GENJUSHEAN《CANGKUZULINHETONG》DISITIAO(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDIERJUANDI44YE),CHENMOUSIBIXUZUNSHOUGUOJIADEFAGUI、FALINGHEZHENGCE,GAOHAOZONGHEZHILI,FUCONGGEGANLIBUMENDEGUANLI,ZAIJINGYINGFANWEINEIHEFAJINGYING,RUWEIFALUANJI,BUFUCONGGUANLI,SUOZAOCHENGDEHOUGUOYIGAIYOUCHENMOUSIZIFU,HOUGUOTEBIEYANZHONGDECHENMOUSANYOUQUANZHONGZHIHETONG。

ZONGSHANG,CHENMOUSANCONGWEIZHIDAOCHENMOUYIDENGJIANGYAOSHISHIHUOSHISHILE“FEIFAQINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUI”DEWURANHUANJINGFANZUIXINGWEI,QIGENGBUKENENGTONGYICHENMOUSIHUOQITAXIANYIRENZAICHANGFANGNEISHISHIWURANHUANJINGDENGBUFAXINGWEI。

三,无论根据在案证据、还是根据陈某三的个人特殊情况,均不能认定陈某三具有环境污染犯罪的故意。

《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN、ZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUAN、GONGANBU、SIFABU、SHENGTAIHUANJINGBUGUANYUBANLIHUANJINGWURANXINGSHIANJIANYOUGUANWENTIZUOTANHUIJIYAO》DIERBUFENDI3TIAOGUIDING: “PANDUANFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENSHIFOUJUYOUHUANJINGWURANFANZUIDEGUYI,YINGDANGYIJUFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENDERENZHIQINGKUANG、ZHIYEJINGLI、ZHUANYEBEIJING、PEIXUNJINGLI、BENRENYINTONGLEIXINGWEISHOUDAOXINGZHENGCHUFAHUOZHEXINGSHIZHUIJIUQINGKUANGYIJIWURANWUZHONGLEI、WURANFANGSHI、ZIJINLIUXIANGDENGZHENGJU,JIEHEQIGONGSHU,JINXINGZONGHEFENXIPANDUAN。”

BIANHURENJINGDUOCIHUIJIANCHENMOUSAN,BINGDUIQISHENGHUOBEIJING、RENZHIQINGKUANG、ZHIYEJINGLI、ZHUANYEBEIJINGDENGJINXINGDIAOCHALEJIEHOU,FAXIANCHENMOUSANCONGWEICANYUHUOCONGSHIGUOFEIJIUSULIAOHUISHOU、CHUZHI、MAIMAIDENGXIANGGUANLINGYUDEJINGYINGHUOSHENGCHANHUODONG。DUIYUSHEANDELAJICHUZHIHUISHOUXINGYE,CHENMOUSANSHIYIGE“WAIXING”,TAGENBENBUZHIDAORUHEHUODESHEANHUOWUHUOWURANWU,GENGBUZHIDAOGAIRUHECHULI、JINGYINGHUOSHENGCHANXIANGGUANHUOWUJIWURANWU,QIGENGSHICONGWEIXIANGBENANQITAXIANYIRENHUORENHEDISANRENTICHUHUOWEITUOTARENSHOUJI、ZHUCUN、LIYONG、CHUZHIWEIXIANWUZHI。CHENMOUSANDUIGAIXINGYEDELEJIEBINGBUHUIBISHEHUISHANGDEPUTONGRENDUO,ZHENGGUIDEKUAISANPINGTAIWUFAQIDAIZHEIYANGYIWEIQISHIDUOSUI、QIEXI“WAIXING”DELAORENJIAQUTONGGUOZHUSIMAJILAIFAXIANYOURENZAICHANGFANGNEISHISHIWURANHUANJINGDENGBUFAXINGWEI。

正规的快三平台ERQIE,JISHISHICHULIFEIJIUSULIAODE“XINGNEIREN”,YEWUFAQINGYIDIQUERENSHIFOUYOURENZAICHANGFANGNEISHISHIWURANHUANJINGDENGBUFAXINGWEI。BIANHURENDUISHEANCHANGFANGJIDANGDIQITATONGLEICHANGFANGSHIDIKAOCHAHOUFAXIAN,SHEANCHANGFANGSIZHOUJUNXIGAOQIANG,MEIYOUKEGONGRENXIANGNEIGUANWANGDECHUANGKOU,CHANGFANGNEIBUYEMEIYOUTONGXIANGCHANGFANGWAIDEPAISHUIQU,WOYEZAIQITATONGLEIXINGRENGZAISHIYONGDECHANGFANGSIZHOUFANFUZOUDONGGUANCHA,FAXIANNANYICONGCHANGFANGWAIGUANCHALEJIECHANGFANGNEIJIUJINGZAIJINXINGHEZHONGSHENGCHANJINGYINGHUODONG。LINGWAI,WOYOUJINRUYIXIEQITATONGLEIXINGDECHANGFANGNEIBUGUANCHA,WOFAXIAN,ZAIMEIYOUXIANGGUANCONGYEJINGYANDERENYUANZHIDAOXIA,WOGENBENWUFAPANDUANXIANGGUANCHANGFANGDAODIJINJINSHIYONGLAICHUCUNSULIAO,HAISHIYONGLAIFENJIANDABAOSULIAODE,HAISHIYONGLAIQINGXIZAISHENGSULIAODE。

LINGWAI,CHENMOUSANMINGXIAYOUDUOCHUSHANGPU、CHANGFANGDENGYONGYUCHUZUHUOJINGYING,TAWANQUANKEYITONGGUOJINGYING、CHUZUZHEIXIECHANYEHUODEKEGUANDEHEFASHOURU,ERZHEIXIEHEFASHOURUZUYISHICHENMOUSANJIQIJIARENGUOSHANGFUZUDESHENGHUO。YINCI,“CHENMOUSANWEILEBAWANYUANDEZUJINERMAOZHEYAOCHENGDANXINGSHIZERENDEFENGXIAN,GUYIWEICHENMOUYIDENGWURANHUANJINGDEFANZUIXINGWEITIGONGCHANGSUO”ZHEIYISHUOFASHIWEIBEICHANGLI、BUFUHECHANGSHIXINGDE。CHENMOUSANWANQUANMEIYOUMAOZHECHENGDANXINGSHIZERENDEFENGXIANQUMOUQULIYIDEXUQIU,TAMEIYOUFANZUIDONGJIYUMUDE。

YINCI,ZAIANZHENGJUWUFAZHENGSHICHENMOUSANCUNZAIFANZUIDONGJI,WUFAZHENGSHICHENMOUSANMINGZHIHUOYINGZHICHENMOUYIDENGSHISHI“FEIFAQINGXISULIAO、PAIFANGFEISHUI”DEWURANHUANJINGFANZUIXINGWEIERRENGRANWEICHENMOUYITIGONGCHANGDI,BUNENGZHENGSHICHENMOUSANYUCHENMOUYIDENGGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUIDEGONGTONGFANZUI。

综上,本案即无客观物证,无法证实陈某一存在通过暗管非法排放废水的行为,无法证实两份监测报告的真实性及关联性,即使两份监测报告真实有效,检测结果均也未能达到污染环境罪的刑事追诉标准,而且,陈某三在客观上没有策划、参与或实施犯罪行为,在主观上无犯罪故意且不具备犯罪动机,在案证据无法支撑对“陈某三与陈某一等构成污染环境罪共同犯罪”的指控,辩护人建议贵院以“本案有证据证明陈某三不构成污染环境罪”为由,在陈某一等被控污染环境罪一案中依法对陈某三作出无罪判决。

 

庭审后补充:

首先,陈某一、陈某二均供述“陈某三不知道他们在C区G镇华美村华辉四路的铁棚内清洗塑料并通过暗管排放废水。”

正规的快三平台ZAITINGSHENDEFATINGDIAOCHAJIEDUAN,SHENPANZHANGJIGONGSURENCENGDUOCIXIANGCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERFAWEN。

正规的快三平台SHENPANZHANGWENCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUER“CHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOCQUGZHENHUAMEICUNHUAHUISILUDETIEPENG”SHI,CHENMOUYIYUCHENMOUERJUNHUIDA“CHENMOUSANQUEYOUDAOGUOJICISHEANTIEPENG。”

正规的快三平台WENCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUER“CHENMOUSANDAOSHEANTIEPENGZUOSHENME?”SHI,CHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERJUNHUIDA“HECHA。”

SHENPANZHANGWENCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUER“CHENMOUSANDAOSHEANTIEPENGSHI,GONGCHANGSHIFOUZHENGZAIZUOYE?”SHI,CHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERHUIDA“YOUZAIFENJIANSULIAO,DANMEIYOUZAIQINGXISULIAOHUOPAIFANGFEISHUI,CHENMOUSANMEIKANDAOGUOQINGXISULIAOHUOPAIFANGFEISHUIDEZUOYE。”

SHENPANZHANGWENCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUER“CHENMOUSANSHIFOUZHIDAONIMENZAISHEANTIEPENGNEIQINGXISULIAO”SHI,CHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERHUIDA“CHENMOUSANBUZHIDAO。”

正规的快三平台TINGSHENZHONGTONGSHITIDAO,CHENMOUSANDAOSHEANTIEPENGNEIHECHA,SHIFOUYIDANJINRUTIEPENGJIUNENGKANDAOYONGYUQINGXISULIAODEXUSHUICHI?SHIFOUBIRANNENGKANDAOYONGYUQINGXISULIAODEGONGJUHUOPAIFANGFEISHUIDEQINGXING?

正规的快三平台DUIZHEIYIWENTI,CHENMOUYIZAIFATINGSHANGHUIDA“QINGXISULIAODEXUSHUICHIYUHECHADEBANGONGSHIWEIYUSHEANTIEPENGDEDUIJIAOSHANG,JULIJIAOYUAN,WUFAKANDAO。”

正规的快三平台BENBIANHURENZAIDUISHEANCHANGSUOJINXINGLEXIANCHANGKAOCHAHOU,FAXIAN,SHEANTIEPENGSHIYIGEMIANJIWEIYIQIANPINGFANGMIZUOYOUDEZHANGFANGXINGCHANGSUO,ERXUSHUICHIYUHECHADEBANGONGSHIFENBIEWEIYUGAICHANGSUODEDUIJIAOXIANDEDUIJIAOSHANG。QIEGAICHANGSUOBEIZHONGJIANDEGEQIANGFENCHENGLIANGGEQUYU,BUZAIXUSHUICHISUOZAIQUYUSHISHIWUFAKANDAOQINGXISULIAOJIPAIFANGFEISHUIDE。(XIANGQINGQINGKANFUJIANYI“SSHICQUGZHENHUAMEICUNHUAHUISILUTIEPENGNEIBUZHAOPIAN”)

 

其次,本案无证据证实陈某三了解涉案的废旧塑料回收处置行业。

GONGSURENZAIFATINGSHANGTICHU“GENJUSSHICQUGZHENDIQUDESHIJIQINGKUANG,CHENMOUSANDAOLESHEANTIEPENGXIANCHANG,KENDINGNENGKANCHUCHENMOUYIDENGZAIGAITIEPENGNEIQINGXISULIAOBINGPAIFANGFEISHUI。”

DANSHI,BIANHURENDAOGZHENDANGDIJINXINGDIAOCHASHIFAXIAN,DANGDIJINGJICHANYELEIXINGBINGBUDANYI,CHULEFEIJIUSULIAOHUISHOUCHUZHICHANYE,HAIYOUTONGYEDENGDENG,BINGBUSHISHUOGZHENDERENDOUYIDINGLEJIEFEIJIUSULIAOHUISHOUCHUZHIXINGYEDEXINXI。

LINGWAI,BIANHURENZAIDIAOCHACHENMOUSANDEJIAOYU、GONGZUOJINGLISHILEJIEDAO,CHENMOUSANCONGWEICANYUHUOCONGSHIGUOFEIJIUSULIAOHUISHOU、CHUZHI、MAIMAIDENGXIANGGUANLINGYUDEJINGYINGHUOSHENGCHANHUODONG。DUIYUSHEANDELAJICHUZHIHUISHOUXINGYE,CHENMOUSANSHIYIGE“WAIXING”,TAGENBENBUZHIDAORUHEHUODESHEANHUOWUHUOWURANWU,GENGBUZHIDAOGAIRUHECHULI、JINGYINGHUOSHENGCHANXIANGGUANHUOWUJIWURANWU,QIGENGSHICONGWEIXIANGBENANQITAXIANYIRENHUORENHEDISANRENTICHUHUOWEITUOTARENSHOUJI、ZHUCUN、LIYONG、CHUZHIWEIXIANWUZHI。CHENMOUSANDUIGAIXINGYEDELEJIEBINGBUHUIBISHEHUISHANGDEPUTONGRENDUO,ZHENGGUIDEKUAISANPINGTAIWUFAQIDAIZHEIYANGYIWEIQISHIDUOSUI、QIEXI“WAIXING”DELAORENJIAQUTONGGUOZHUSIMAJILAIFAXIANYOURENZAICHANGFANGNEISHISHIWURANHUANJINGDENGBUFAXINGWEI。

正规的快三平台JISHISHICHULIFEIJIUSULIAODE“XINGNEIREN”,YEWUFAQINGYIDIQUERENSHIFOUYOURENZAICHANGFANGNEISHISHIWURANHUANJINGDENGBUFAXINGWEI。BIANHURENDUISHEANCHANGFANGJIDANGDIQITATONGLEICHANGFANGSHIDIKAOCHAHOUFAXIAN,SHEANCHANGFANGSIZHOUJUNXIGAOQIANG,MEIYOUKEGONGRENXIANGNEIGUANWANGDECHUANGKOU,CHANGFANGNEIBUYEMEIYOUTONGXIANGCHANGFANGWAIDEPAISHUIQU,WOYEZAIQITATONGLEIXINGRENGZAISHIYONGDECHANGFANGSIZHOUFANFUZOUDONGGUANCHA,FAXIANNANYICONGCHANGFANGWAIGUANCHALEJIECHANGFANGNEIJIUJINGZAIJINXINGHEZHONGSHENGCHANJINGYINGHUODONG。LINGWAI,ZAIJINRUYIXIEQITATONGLEIXINGDECHANGFANGNEIBUGUANCHASHI,WOFAXIANZAIMEIYOUXIANGGUANCONGYEJINGYANDERENYUANZHIDAOXIA,PUTONGRENGENBENWUFAPANDUANXIANGGUANCHANGFANGDAODIJINJINSHIYONGLAICHUCUNSULIAO,HAISHIYONGLAIFENJIANDABAOSULIAO,HAISHIYONGLAIQINGXIZAISHENGSULIAODE。

ERQIE,GONGSURENBINGWEITIJIAONENGZHICHIZHEIYIZHIKONGDEZHENGJU,BENANMEIYOURENHEZHENGJUNENGZHENGSHICHENMOUSANLEJIESHEANDEFEIJIUSULIAOHUISHOUCHUZHIXINGYE。

正规的快三平台ZAICI,CHENMOUSANWUFANZUIDONGJI。

正规的快三平台BIANHURENZAIDIAOCHAZHONGCHENMOUSANDEJINGJIZHUANGKUANGSHIFAXIAN,CHENMOUSANMINGXIAYOUDUOCHUSHANGPU、CHANGFANGDENGYONGYUCHUZUHUOJINGYING,TAWANQUANKEYITONGGUOJINGYING、CHUZUZHEIXIECHANYEHUODEKEGUANDEHEFASHOURU,ERZHEIXIEHEFASHOURUZUYISHICHENMOUSANJIQIJIARENGUOSHANGFUZUDESHENGHUO。YINCI,“CHENMOUSANWEILEBAWANYUANDEZUJINERMAOZHEYAOCHENGDANXINGSHIZERENDEFENGXIAN,GUYIWEICHENMOUYIDENGWURANHUANJINGDEFANZUIXINGWEITIGONGCHANGSUO”ZHEIYISHUOFASHIWEIBEICHANGLI、BUFUHECHANGSHIXINGDE。CHENMOUSANWANQUANMEIYOUMAOZHECHENGDANXINGSHIZERENDEFENGXIANQUMOUQULIYIDEXUQIU,TAMEIYOUFANZUIDONGJIYUMUDE。

最后,结合全案证据,足以证实陈某三无罪。

GUANYUZHEIYIDIAN,BIANHURENZAIZHIQIANTIJIAODEBIANHUCIYIJINGYOUGUODUOCILUNSHU,YIJINGSHUOGUODE,CICHUBUZAIZHUISHU,XIANJIUZHENDUIGONGSURENZAITINGSHENSHISUOTIGUANDIANJINXINGBIANHU。

TINGSHENQIJIAN,GONGSURENTICHU“BENANZHENGJUZUYIZHENGSHICHENMOUSANMINGZHICHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERQINGXISULIAOBINGTONGGUOANGUANPAIFANGFEISHUIERRENGRANTIGONGCHANGSUORANGCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERSHISHIFANZUIXINGWEI。”

正规的快三平台DANSHI,GONGSURENZISHIZHIZHONGWEINENGZHICHUBENANDENAYIXIANGZHENGJUNENGGOUZHICHENGZHEIYIZHIKONG。WEISHENME?YUANYINHENJIANDAN,YINWEIBENANGENBENMEIYOURENHEZHENGJUKEYIZHENGSHICHENMOUSANZAIZHUGUANSHANGDE“MINGZHI”HUOCUNZAIFANZUIGUYI,LIAN“GUZHENG”DOUMEIYOU!!!

ERXIANGFANDE,BENANYOUZUGOUDUODEZHENGJUZHENGSHICHENMOUSANGENBENBUZHIDAOCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERDENGZAISHEANCHANGSUONEIQINGXISULIAOBINGTONGGUOANGUANPAIFANGFEISHUI。

正规的快三平台RANGZHENGGUIDEKUAISANPINGTAILAIKANKANLINGWAILIANGMINGBEIGAOCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERYIJIZHENGRENCHENMOUSIDEGONGSHU。

CHENMOUYIZAIQIXUNWENBILUZHONGGONGSHU: “……WEN: CUOZHUCHENMOUSANZAINIJIESHOUZUOFANGQIJIANSHIFOUYOUQUGUOGAIZUOFANG?DA: YOUQUGUOJICI,JUTIDUOSHAOCIWOJIBUQINGCHU。WEN: CHENMOUSANMEICIDAONIZUOFANGSHI,ZUOFANGSHIFOUYOUZAIZUOYE?DA: YOUSHIHOUYOU,YOUSHIHOUMEIYOU。WEN: CHENMOUSANDAONIZUOFANGSHI,NIZUOFANGDEZUOYEZHUANGKUANG?DA: TADAOHOU,GONGRENZHISHIZAIWOZUOFANGFENJIANSULIAO。WEN: CHENMOUSANDAONIZUOFANGSHI,SHIFOUYOUKANJIANNIMENZAIQINGXISULIAO?DA: MEIYOU。WEN: TASHIFOUZHIDAONIZUOFANGZAICONGSHIQINGXISULIAOZUOYE?DA: TABUQINGCHU,WOMEIYOUHETASHUOGUO。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI133、134YE),“……WEN: NIJIESHOUQIAN,NIFUQINKAISHEDEZUOFANGSHIZAICONGSHIHESHENGCHAN?DA: CONGSHIFENJIANSULIAOZUOYE。…….WEN: NIFUQINCHENMOUSISHIFOUQINGCHUNIZAIGAIZUOFANGCONGSHIFENSUI、QINGXIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOYE?DA: TABUQINGCHU。……WEN: CHENMOUSANSHIFOUQINGCHUNIZAIGAICHANGDIGANSHENME?DA: DANGSHISHIWOFUQINHETAZUDE,TASHIFOUQINGCHUZULAIGANSHENMEDEWOYEBUZHIDAO。(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI151、155YE)”

CHENMOUERZAIQIXUNWEN、XUNWEN、BIANRENBILUZHONGGONGSHU: “……WEN: NISHIFOURENSHINIDAGONGDEZUOFANGCUOZHU?DA: WOBURENSHI。WEN: CUOZHUSHIFOUYOUDAOGUOGAIZUOFANG?DA: WOBURENSHITA,WOBUQINGCHUGAIZUOFANGCUOZHUSHIFOUYOULAIGUOGAIZUOFANG。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI166YE),“……WEN: GAIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOFANGDECHANGDISHISHEIDE?DA: WOTINGLAOBANSHUOCHANGDISHIXIANGBIERENZUDE,JUTIXIANGSHEIZUDEWOBUQINGCHU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI170YE),“……WEN: GAIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOFANGDECUOZHUSHISHEI?DA: WOTINGLAOBANSHUOCHANGDISHIXIANGBIERENZUDE,JUTIXIANGSHEIZUDEWOBUQINGCHU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI175YE),“……WEN: GAIFEIJIUSULIAOZUOFANGDECUOZHUSHISHEI?DA: WOTINGLAOBANSHUOCHANGDISHIXIANGBIERENZUDE,JUTIXIANGSHEIZUDEWOBUQINGCHU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI180YE),“JINGWOBIANRENZHAOPIANZHONGDERENWODOUBURENSHI。”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI188YE)

CHENMOUSIZAIQIXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUZHONGDEGONGSHU: “WEN: NIXIANGCHENMOUSANZUYONGTIEPIWUZUOHESHENGYI?DA: WOZULAIKAISHEFEIJIUSULIAOFENJIANGONGCHANG。……WEN: NIJINGYINGGONGCHANGQIJIANDESHENGCHANLIUCHENGSHIZENYANGDE?DA: GONGRENDUIFEIJIUSULIAOJINXINGFENJIANFENLEI,RANHOUDABAOCHUSHOU。WEN: GONGCHANGZAIZUOYEGONGCHENGZHONGSHIFOUHUICHANSHENGFEISHUI?DA: BUHUICHANSHENGFEISHUI。……WEN: CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUSHIFOUYOUDUIFEIJIUSULIAOJINXINGQINGXI?DA: WOBUQINGCHU。WEN: CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANG?DA: ZAIWOJINGYINGQIJIAN,CHENMOUSANOUERYOUDAOGONGCHANGZHAOWOXIANLIAOHECHA,CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANGLAIWOJIUBUQINGCHULE。WEN: NIJINGYINGQIJIANSHIFOUYOUDUISULIAOJINXINGQINGXI?DA: MEIYOU。……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI124、 125YE),“……WEN: CHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANG?DA: ZAIWOJINGYINGQIJIANCHENMOUSANOUERYOUDAOGONGCHANGLAIXIANLIAOHECHA,2018NIAN11YUECHENMOUYIJIESHOUGONGCHANGHOUCHENMOUSANSHIFOUDAOGUOGONGCHANGLAIWOJIUBUQINGCHULE。……WEN: NIBENRENKAIBANHEJINGYINGFEIJIUSULIAOGONGCHANGQIJIANSHIFOUHUIDUIHUANJINGHUIZAOCHENGWURAN?DA: WOZHISHIDUIFEIJIUSULIAOJINXINGFENJIAN,BUHUIDUIHUANJINGHUIZAOCHENGWURAN。”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI129、130YE)

正规的快三平台CHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERJUNJIESHOULEDUOCIXUNWEN,QIETAMENDEGONGSHUZISHIZHIZHONGDOUHENYIZHI,ERBENANTINGSHENFATINGDIAOCHASHI,TAMENDEGONGSHURENGYUXUNWENBILUZHONGDEGONGSHUBAOCHIYIZHI,KEXINDUJIGAO。ERZHENGRENCHENMOUSIYEJIESHOULEDUOCIXUNWEN,QIGONGSHUYESHIZHONGYIZHI,KEXINDUJIAOGAO。ZUIGUANJIANDESHI,BEIGAOCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERYUZHENGRENCHENMOUSIDEZHENGYANSHIKEYIXIANGHUYINZHENGDE,XIANERYIJIANDI,CISANRENDEGONGSHUDOUZHENGMINGZHETONGYIGESHISHI---“CHENMOUSANZAIZHUGUANSHANGBUZHIDAOCHENMOUYI、CHENMOUERDENGZAISHEANCHANGSUONEIQINGXISULIAOBINGTONGGUOANGUANPAIFANGFEISHUI。”

综上全部,陈某三在主观上并不“明知”,他没有帮助陈某一、陈某二等清洗塑料并通过暗管排放废水的故意,而客观上陈某三也不具备“明知陈某一、陈某二清洗塑料并通过暗管排放废水”的可能性。因此,陈某三并不存在指控的犯罪事实,而在案证据足以证实陈某三无罪。

 

 

 

第二部分

BENANCHENMOUSANCANYUHUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGZUISHISHIBUQING、ZHENGJUBUZU,YIFAYINGYI“ZHENGJUBUZU、ZHIKONGDEFANZUIBUNENGCHENGLI”DUICHENMOUSANXUANGAOWUZUI。JIANYIGUIYUANGENJU《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DIERBAITIAODEGUIDINGBOHUIGONGSURENDUICHENMOUSANDEZHIKONG,YIFAZUOCHUWUZUIPANJUE。

 

首先,(2018)粤XXXX刑初XXX号案件没有追究陈某三的刑事责任。

GUIYUANZAI(2018)YUEXXXXXINGCHUXXXHAOPANJUESHUZHONGRENWEI:

“BEIGAORENHUANGMOU、WANGMOUYIWUSHIGUOJIAFALV,WEIFANGUOJIAGUIDING,WUWEIXIANFEIWUJINGYINGXUKEZHENGFEIFACHUZHIWEIXIANFEIWU,YANZHONGWURANHUANJING,FANGHAIGUOJIADUIWEIXIANFEIWUDEANQUANGUANLIZHIDU,QIXINGWEIJUNYIGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUI。SHUGONGTONGFANZUI。GONGSUJIGUANZHIKONGBEIGAORENHUANGMOU、WANGMOUYIFANWURANHUANJINGZUIDESHISHIQINGCHU,ZHENGJUQUESHI、CHONGFEN,ZHIKONGDEZUIMINGCHENGLI。”

GUIYUANPANJUE:

正规的快三平台“YI、BEIGAORENHUANGMOUFANWURANHUANJINGZUI,PANCHUYOUQITUXINGSHIGEYUE,HUANXINGYINIAN,BINGCHUFAJINERWANYUAN。(HUANXINGKAOYANQIXIAN,CONGPANJUEQUEDINGZHIRIQIJISUAN。)

正规的快三平台ER、BEIGAORENWANGMOUYIFANWURANHUANJINGZUI,PANCHUYOUQITUXINGBAGEYUE,HUANXINGYINIAN,BINGCHUFAJINYIWANYUAN。(HUANXINGKAOYANQIXIAN,CONGPANJUEQUEDINGZHIRIQIJISUAN。)”

正规的快三平台GUIYUANRENDINGDEDINGANYIJUYOU:

“1、ZHENGRENZUOMOUDEZHENGYANJIBIANRENBILU……2、ZHENGRENLIAOMOUYI、WANGMOUER、LIAOMOUER、LIMOUYIDEZHENGYANJUNYINZHENGZHENGRENZUOMOUDEZHENGYAN……3、BEIGAORENHUANGMOUYUANZAIGONGANJIGUANDEGONGSHUJIBIANRENBILU……4、BEIGAORENWANGMOUYIYUANZAIGONGANJIGUANDEGONGSHUJIBIANRENBILU……5、‘SHOUANDENGJIBIAO’、‘ZHUAHUOJINGGUO’HE‘JIANCHABILU’……6、SSHICQUHUANJINGBAOHUJU‘SHEXIANFANZUIANJIANYISONGSHU’……7、‘XIANCHANGKANYANBILU’……8、‘SSHICQUGZHENHUANJINGBAOHUFENJUJIANDUGUANLIXIANCHANGJIANCHABILU’……9、SSHICQUGZHENRENMINZHENGFUCHUJUDE‘QINGKUANGSHUOMING’HE‘GUOBANGDAN’……10、SSHICQUHUANJINGBAOHUJUCHUJUDE‘RENDINGYIJIANSHU’……11、XINGSHIXIANGPIAN……12、CHANGZHURENKOUJIBENXINXI。”

其次,在(2018)粤XXXX刑初XXX号案件中,各办案机关均认为陈某三不构成犯罪,该案证据无法证实陈某三构成污染环境罪。

正规的快三平台GENJU《XINGSHISUSONGFA》DIYIBAIQISHIYITIAO,RENMINJIANCHAYUANSHENCHAANJIANDESHIHOU,BIXUCHAMING:

  (YI)FANZUISHISHI、QINGJIESHIFOUQINGCHU,ZHENGJUSHIFOUQUESHI、CHONGFEN,FANZUIXINGZHIHEZUIMINGDERENDINGSHIFOUZHENGQUE;

  (ER)YOUWUYILOUZUIXINGHEQITAYINGDANGZHUIJIUXINGSHIZERENDEREN;

  (SAN)SHIFOUSHUYUBUYINGZHUIJIUXINGSHIZERENDE;

正规的快三平台  (SI)YOUWUFUDAIMINSHISUSONG;

  (WU)ZHENCHAHUODONGSHIFOUHEFA。

DANSHI,(2018)YUEXXXXXINGCHUXXXHAOANJIANZILIANDAOPANJUE,JIANCHAYUANSHIZHONGWEIZHUIJIUCHENMOUSANDEXINGSHIZEREN。LINGWAI,WOZAIHUIJIANCHENMOUSANSHIBEIGAOZHI,CHENMOUSANZAI2018NIANJIANYINWEISHENTIJIANKANGQIANJIA,CHANGNIANZAIJIAXIUYANG,QIZAISHOUDAOGONGANJIGUANFACHUDE《CHUANHUANZHENG》(SGONGCCHUANHUANZI[2017]00579HAO)SHI,YOUYUQIAQIAOXUYAOQIANWANGYIYUANZHIBING,ERWUFADAOANJIESHOUXUNWEN,DANSHI,SHIHOUBANANJIGUANYIYIZHIWEIDUICHENMOUSANCAIQUZHUABU、TONGJIDENGRENHEQIANGZHICHENMOUSANGUIANDECUOSHI。

YINCI,CONG(2018)YUEXXXXXINGCHUXXXHAOANJIANDEPANJUEJIEGUOKEZHI,JIESHIGEBANANJIGUANJUNRENWEICHENMOUSANBUGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUI,JINPING(2018)YUEXXXXXINGCHUXXXHAOANJIANZHONGDEZHENGJUYUSHISHI,SHIBUYINGZHUIJIUCHENMOUSANDEXINGSHIZERENDE。

最后,综合(2020)粤XXXX刑初XXX号案全案证据,没有证据能证实陈某三在黄某等污染环境犯罪案中也构成污染环境罪。

正规的快三平台CHUQUE(2018)YUEXXXXXINGCHUXXXHAOZHONGDEZHENGJUCAILIAOWAI,NENGZHUIJIUCHENMOUSANXIHUANGMAODENGWURANHUANJINGZUIGONGFANDEZHENGJUBIANZHIYOUCHENMOUSANZAI2019NIAN11YUE29RI18SHI16FENZHI2019NIAN11YUE29RI20SHI26FENXUNWENBILUDI5YEZHONGDEGONGSHULE。

DANSHI,WOZAIHUIJIANCHENMOUSANSHI,QUEBEIGAOZHIYIXIASHISHI(YIXIANEIRONGSHEMI,BUYUGONGSHI):

1、……。

2、……。

3、……。

……

综上,本案根本没有任何证据能证实陈某三构成黄某等污染环境罪的共同犯罪,应当依法按“证据不足、指控的犯罪不能成立”宣告陈某三无罪。

 

另外,退一万步,即使陈某三系黄某等污染环境的共犯,但陈某三在案件中起到的作用最低、最轻微,且其存在自首情节,对其量刑应当轻于(2018)粤XXXX刑初XXX号案件中的另两位被告人。

首先,办案机关是在陈某三主动归案并主动供述后才掌握陈某三参与黄某等污染环境犯罪的相关事实的,因此本案中,陈某三是自首。

GENJU《XINGFA》DILIUSHIQITIAO,FANZUIYIHOUZIDONGTOUAN,RUSHIGONGSHUZIJIDEZUIXINGDE,SHIZISHOU。DUIYUZISHOUDEFANZUIFENZI,KEYICONGQINGHUOZHEJIANQINGCHUFA。QIZHONG,FANZUIJIAOQINGDE,KEYIMIANCHUCHUFA。BEICAIQUQIANGZHICUOSHIDEFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENHEZHENGZAIFUXINGDEZUIFAN,RUSHIGONGSHUSIFAJIGUANHAIWEIZHANGWODEBENRENQITAZUIXINGDE,YIZISHOULUN。

CONG(2018)YUEXXXXXINGCHUXXXHAOANJIANDEBANLIGUOCHENGJIPANJUEJIEGUOKEZHI,CHENMOUSANGUIANQIAN,GEBANANJIGUANJUNWEIZHANGWOCHENMOUSANXIHUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGZUIGONGFANDEZHENGJUYUSHISHI。

(2020)粤XXXX刑初XXX正规的快三平台号案之所以会追究陈某三在黄某等犯污染环境罪一案中的刑事责任,全凭陈某三在2019年11月29日18时16分至2019年11月29日20时26分询问笔录(S市公安局C区分局刑事侦查卷宗第三卷第202至207页)第5页中的供述。

2019NIAN11YUE29RI18SHI16FENZHI2019NIAN11YUE29RI20SHI26FENXUNWENBILUXIANSHI: “BANANRENYUANWEN: ‘NISHIFOUYOUBUCHONG?’CHENMOUSANDA: ‘2017NIAN5YUE,WOJIANGWEIYUCQUGZHENHUAMEIHUAXIANGPIANQUDAYUEERBAIDUOPINGFANGDETIEPENGZUJIEJIJIAOHUANGMOUDEZHEJIANGRENKAISHEFEIJIUDIANQIHEFEIJIUDIANCHICHAIJIEGONGCHANG,NIANZUJIN60000YUAN。’……”(SSHIGONGANJUCQUFENJUXINGSHIZHENCHAJUANZONGDISANJUANDI206YE)

ERQIE,CONG2019NIAN11YUE29RI18SHI16FENZHI2019NIAN11YUE29RI20SHI26FENXUNWENBILUKEZHI,BANANRENYUANZAIXUNWENGUOCHENGZHONG,ZAICHENMOUSANZHUDONGGONGSHU“JIANGWEIYUCQUGZHENHUAMEIHUAXIANGPIANQUDAYUEERBAIDUOPINGFANGDETIEPENGZUJIEJIJIAOHUANGMOUDEZHEJIANGRENKAISHEFEIJIUDIANQIHEFEIJIUDIANCHICHAIJIEGONGCHANG”QIAN,BINGWEIWENJICHENMOUSANRENHEGUANYU“HUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGFANZUIYIAN”DEWENTI。

正规的快三平台YOUCIKEJIAN,ZAICHENMOUSANZHUDONGGONGSHUQIAN,BANANJIGUANBINGWEIZHANGWOCHENMOUSANCANYUHUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGFANZUIDEXIANGGUANSHISHI。YINCI,YIFAYINGDANGRENDINGCHENMOUSANZAIBENANZHONGGOUCHENGZISHOU。

 

其次,陈某三在黄某等犯污染环境罪一案中为黄某等提供作案场所,仅起次要作用,是从犯。

GENJU《XINGFA》DIERSHIQITIAO,ZAIGONGTONGFANZUIZHONGQICIYAOHUOZHEFUZHUZUOYONGDE,SHICONGFAN。DUIYUCONGFAN,YINGDANGCONGQING、JIANQINGCHUFAHUOZHEMIANCHUCHUFA。

GENJUCHENMOUSANZAIQIXUNWEN、XUNWENBILUZHONGDEGONGSHU,YIJIZHENGRENLIAOMOUYI、WANGMOUER、LIAOMOUER、LIMOUYIDEZHENGYANKEZHI,CHENMOUSANZAIHUANGMOUDENGFANWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANZHONGSUOQIDEZUOYONGSHIWEIHUANGMOUDENGTIGONGZUOANCHANGSUO。

DANSHI,GENJUSHANGSHUBILUTONGSHIKEZHI,CHENMOUSANCHULEXIANGHUANGMOUDENGTIGONGCHANGSUOBINGSHOUQUZUJINWAI,QIYUHUANGMOUDENGBINGWURENHEQITADELIYIWANGLAI,HUANGMOUDENGCHAIJIEFEIJIUDIANQI、FEIJIUDIANCHIDESHENGYIYUCHENMOUSANYEBUCUNZAIRENHEGUANXI,CHENMOUSANYEWEIZAIHUANGMOUDECHAIJIEGONGSINEIDANRENRENHEZHIWU,GENGWEILINGQUGUORENHEBAOCHOU。

WOZAIZOUFANGGZHENDETONGLEIXINGTIEPENGZULINSHICHANGHOUFAXIAN,CHENMOUSANYINIANZUJIN6WANYUANZUJIHUANGMOUDENGERBAIPINGFANGMIDETIEPENGXIFUHESHICHANGDINGJIADE,QIBINGWEIBIANXIANGXIANGHUANGMOUDENGSHOUSHOUGAOEBAOCHOU。ERQIE,ZHEITONGSHIYESHUOMINGLE,CHENMOUSANSHIFOUBASHEANTIEPENGZUJIHUANGMOU,BINGBUSHIHUANGMOUSHISHIWURANHUANJINGFANZUIDEBIYAOTIAOJIAN,JISHICHENMOUSANBUBASHEANTIEPENGZUYUHUANGMOU,HUANGMOUYEWANQUANKEYIYITONGYANGDEHUOGENGDIDEZUJINZUDAOQITADEZUOANCHANGSUO。YINCI,CHENMOUSANZAIHUANGMOUDENGFANWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANZHONGSUOQIDAODEZUOYONGSHIZUIXIAODE,QICONGFANDIWEIYINGDANGGENGDIYUWANGMOUYI。

LINGWAI,BIANHURENSOUJISHENYUELEYIBAIQISHIJIUZONGSSHIDIQUJINJINIANDEWURANHUANJINGFANZUIANJIAN,FAXIANCHUZURENYIBANDOUBUHUIBEIRENDINGWEIGOUCHENGWURANHUANJINGZUI,JISHIZUICHENG,YESHIYI“ZAIANJIANZHONGZUOYONGZUIXIAO、DIWEIZUIDIDECONGFAN”LAIJINXINGCHUFA。WEICI,WOTIAOXUANCHULEQIZHONGBIJIAODIANXINGDESHIBAZONGANJIAN,TIJIAOJIHEYITINGYIBIANCANKAO。(XIANGQINGQINGJIANFUJIANER“CANKAOANLI”)

 

最后,陈某三主动对本案认罪认罚,具备悔罪表现,社会危害性极低。

正规的快三平台GENJU《ZUIGAORENMINFAYUAN、ZUIGAORENMINJIANCHAYUAN、GONGANBU、GUOJIAANQUANBU、SIFABUGUANYUSHIYONGRENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUDEZHIDAOYIJIAN》(XIAWENCHENGRENZUIRENFAYIJIAN)DIWUTIAO,SHIYONGJIEDUANHESHIYONGANJIANFANWEI。RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUGUANCHUANXINGSHISUSONGQUANGUOCHENG,SHIYONGYUZHENCHA、QISU、SHENPANGEGEJIEDUAN。DILIUTIAO,“RENZUI”DEBAWO。RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUZHONGDE“RENZUI”,SHIZHIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZIYUANRUSHIGONGSHUZIJIDEZUIXING,DUIZHIKONGDEFANZUISHISHIMEIYOUYIYI。CHENGRENZHIKONGDEZHUYAOFANZUISHISHI,JINDUIGEBIESHISHIQINGJIETICHUYIYI,HUOZHESUIRANDUIXINGWEIXINGZHITICHUBIANJIEDANBIAOSHIJIESHOUSIFAJIGUANRENDINGYIJIANDE,BUYINGXIANG“RENZUI”DERENDING。

正规的快三平台GONGSURENZAITINGSHENQIJIANTICHU: “CHENMOUSANMINGZHIHUANGMOUDENGYAOFEIFACUNFANG、CHAIJIEFEIJIUXIANLUBANHEFEIJIUGENIEDIANCHIERRENGWEIQITIGONGCHANGSUO。”

BIANHURENZAITINGSHENSHIXIANGCHENMOUSANFAWEN: “NISHIFOUYUANYIDUINISHEHUANGMOUDENGFANWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANRENZUIRENFA?”CHENMOUSANHUIDA: “YUANYIRENZUIRENFA。”

正规的快三平台BIANHURENZAIHUIJIANCHENMOUSANSHIXIANGQIFAWEN: “DUIYUSSHICQURENMINJIANCHAYUANDUINI‘MINGZHIHUANGMOUDENGYAOFEIFACUNFANG、CHAIJIEFEIJIUXIANLUBANHEFEIJIUGENIEDIANCHIERRENGWEIQITIGONGCHANGSUO’DEZHIKONG,NISHIFOURENZUI?”CHENMOUSANSHUO: “WORENZUI。”

YOUCIKEJIAN,CHENMOUSANSHICHENGRENGONGSURENZAIHUANGMOUDENGFANWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANZHONGDUICHENMOUSANDEZHIKONGDE,GAICHENGRENFUHE《RENZUIRENFAYIJIAN》ZHONGGUANYU“RENZUI”DEGUIDING,SHIRENZUI。

YOUGENJU《RENZUIRENFAYIJIAN》DI7TIAO,“RENFA”DEBAWO。RENZUIRENFACONGKUANZHIDUZHONGDE“RENFA”,SHIZHIFANZUIXIANYIREN、BEIGAORENZHENCHENGHUIZUI,YUANYIJIESHOUCHUFA。“RENFA”,ZAIZHENCHAJIEDUANBIAOXIANWEIBIAOSHIYUANYIJIESHOUCHUFA;ZAISHENCHAQISUJIEDUANBIAOXIANWEIJIESHOURENMINJIANCHAYUANNIZUOCHUDEQISUHUOBUQISUJUEDING,RENKERENMINJIANCHAYUANDELIANGXINGJIANYI,QIANSHURENZUIRENFAJUJIESHU;ZAISHENPANJIEDUANBIAOXIANWEIDANGTINGQUERENZIYUANQIANSHUJUJIESHU,YUANYIJIESHOUXINGFACHUFA。

BIANHURENZAIHUIJIANCHENMOUSANSHI,ZAIBEIGAOZHICHENGRENGONGSURENDUIQI“MINGZHIHUANGMOUDENGYAOFEIFACUNFANG、CHAIJIEFEIJIUXIANLUBANHEFEIJIUGENIEDIANCHIERRENGWEIQITIGONGCHANGSUO”DEZHIKONGHOU,GAOZHICHENMOUSAN: “RENZUIHOU,YIDANBEIRENDINGWEIYOUZUI,SHIYAOXINGSHIZERENDE,NISHIFOUYUANYIJIESHOUNIYINCANYUHUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANERYINGSHOUDEXINGSHICHUFA?”CHENMOUSANHUIDAO: “YUANYIJIESHOU。”SUIHOU,BIANHURENBARENZUIRENFADEGUOCHENGJIXIANGGUANGUIDINGGAOZHILECHENMOUSAN,CHENMOUSANBIAOSHIYUANYIQIANSHOU《LIANGXINGJIANYISHU》BINGYUANYIQIANSHU《RENZUIRENFAJUJIESHU》。

正规的快三平台YOUCIKEJIAN,CHENMOUSANZAIBIANHURENGAOZHIQIRENZUIDEHOUGUOSHIXUYAOJIESHOUXINGSHICHUFAHOU,QIBIAOSHIYUANYIJIESHOUCHUFABINGQIANSHU《RENZUIRENFAJUJIESHU》,SHIRENFA。

CHUQUERENZUIJIYUANYIJIESHOUXINGSHICHUFAWAI,CHENMOUSANHAIGAOZHIBIANHUREN,TAYIJINGSHENKEYISHIDAOZIJISUOFANDECUOWU,QIEJIANJUEBUHUIZAIFAN,WEICI,QIYIJINGZAICHUSHOUSHEANDECQUGZHENHUAMEIHUAXIANGPIANQUDAYUEERBAIDUOPINGFANGTIEPENG,DANYINSHICHANGBUJIA,WUFAMASHANGCHUSHOUCHENGGONG,DANYIDANTIEPENGCHUSHOU,CHENMOUSANBIANBUKENENGZAIWEIRENHERENTIGONG“ZUOANCHANGSUO”。

BIANHURENRENWEI,CHENMOUSANCHENGRENGONGSURENDUIQI“MINGZHIHUANGMOUDENGYAOFEIFACUNFANG、CHAIJIEFEIJIUXIANLUBANHEFEIJIUGENIEDIANCHIERRENGWEIQITIGONGCHANGSUO”DEZHIKONG,QIEYUANYIJIESHOUXINGSHICHUFA,SHIRENZUIRENFA,QIEQIZHUDONGCHENGNUOYIHOUJIANJUEBUHUIZAIFANBINGCHUSHOUCQUGZHENHUAMEIHUAXIANGPIANQUDAYUEERBAIDUOPINGFANGTIEPENGDEDEXINGWEIJUYOUHUIZUIYISHI

ZONGSHANG,CHENMOUSANZAIHUANGMOUDENGFANWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANZHONGSHICONGFAN,YOUZISHOUQINGJIE,QIEYUANYIRENZUIRENFABINGHUIZUI,YIFAYINGDANGDUIQICONGQING、JIANQINGHUOMIANCHUCHUFA。CHENMOUSANZAIGAIANZHONGSUOQIDEZUOYONGZUIWEIQINGWEI,SUOCHUDIWEIYAOGENGDIYUHUANGMOU、WANGMOUYI,ZAICI,WEIBAOZHENGSIFADEGONGZHENG,YIFADANGQIZUI,WOQINGQIUGUIYUANZAICHENMOUSANSHEXIANCANYUHUANGMOUDENGWURANHUANJINGZUIYIANZHONG,DUICHENMOUSANCHUYIQINGYUHUANGMOUJIWANGMOUYIDEXINGFA。

CIZHI

SSHICQURENMINFAYUAN

 

BIANHUREN: GUANGDONGGUANGQIANGZHENGGUIDEKUAISANPINGTAILINHANGLVSHI

BIANHURENQIANMING:

TIJIAORIQI:        NIAN   YUE   RI


阅读量: 621 PC版链接

林航
林航毒品、经济犯罪案件辩护律师、广强正规的快三平台毒品犯罪辩护与研究中心核心律师
证件号:054805
紧急刑事案件咨询可直接加广强正规的快三平台案管专员手机: )
如情况紧急,请直接致电: 电话:
推荐专题
江苏陆某被控贪污罪、挪用公款罪一案(挪用公款罪不成立)
张某被控盗窃罪一案 (取保终无罪)
曾X华被控贪污罪一案(缓刑)
汪某胜被控贪污罪一案(不起诉)
赖某被控非法经营罪一案(不起诉)
原央视主持人方宏进被控合同诈骗罪一案(不起诉)
王艺被控合同诈骗罪一案(无罪)
雷庭被判非法拘禁罪一案(终获无罪)
李某甲被控参加黑社会性质组织罪、非法采矿罪一案(不起诉)
马勇明等被判贩卖毒品罪一案(无罪)
推荐阅读
非法吸收公众存款罪案件不予批准逮捕得以释放的八种情形
王思鲁: 关于刑事律师的“真货”营销
拒绝迟夙生律师出庭,实际是侵犯了被告人明经国的权利
广强农村两委犯罪案件辩护与研究中心简介
七年了!今天,被告人高海东被控故意伤害案终于落下帷幕!
对虚开增值税专用发票罪中介绍行为的有效辩护研究
没有纸上谈兵的刑事辩护
关于办理刑事案件严格排除非法证据若干问题的规定
“大妈讨债团”是黑社会性质组织吗?
贷款诈骗罪相关法律法规(2017版)
最新文章
民间借贷,即将告别24%和36%?对刑事案件有何影响?
猛虎辩护
陈某某涉嫌诈骗罪一案(正在办理中)
唐某某涉嫌敲诈勒索罪一案(正在办理中)
为什么刑事会见那么重要?
委托刑事律师,需要走怎样的流程?
罗某某涉嫌组织、领导、参加黑社会性质组织罪,寻衅滋事罪,非法拘禁罪一案(正在办理中)
从一起借钱投资证券、期货被控诈骗罪判例看无罪是如何认定的?
《最高人民检察院公安部关于公安机关办理经济犯罪案件的若干规定》解读
【广强正规的快三平台诈骗犯罪辩护与研究中心招聘公告】

JINJIZHONGDAXINGSHIANJIANZIXUNKEZHIJIEJIAGUANGQIANGZHENGGUIDEKUAISANPINGTAIZHUREN、XINGSHIDAYAOANBIANHULVSHIWANGSILUWEIXINXIANGTAFANYING(TONGGUOWANGLVSHISHOUJI)

正规的快三平台RUQINGKUANGJINJI,QINGZHIJIEZHIDIAN: DIANHUA

DIZHI: GUANGZHOUSHIYUEXIUQUTIANHELU45HAOHENGJIANDASHA23LOU(DITIEDONGWUYUANZHANCCHUKOUZHIZOU400MIZUOYOU,DONGFENGDONGLUXIAOXUETIANLUNXIAOQUPANG,YUANMINGTIANLUNDASHA。)

YOUZHENGBIANMA: 510600

Copyright © 2006-2020 正规的快三平台

正规的快三平台 快三平台app下载安装 快三平台首充送彩金 快三平台登录 快三平台下载地址 快三平台代理 网信彩票快三平台 亚投彩票快三平台 江苏快三平台下载安装 快三平台官网下载 快三平台官网正规